Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

MA-05 candidates clash on experience

August 28, 2007 By Charley on the MTA 20 Comments

Dick Howe’s got a rundown of the final debate between the MA-05 candidates. Eileen Donoghue is making a run at Niki Tsongas’ experience — portraying herself as a seasoned public servant and Tsongas as, well, a political wife who didn’t have much enthusiasm for politics. (Jim Miceli’s doing the same thing, but nobody cares about him.) Anyway, I dunno if that sticks … seems to me if you’re willing to throw yourself into the hassle of a Congressional race, you’re probably prepared to serve with some vigor. I suppose I could be wrong.

This cuts a little closer to the bone — from Dick’s notes of an exchange between Donoghue and Tsongas:

Donoghue says “You raised over $1 mil and you sound like you don?t want any competition.”  Donoghue replies pretty forcefully about leadership not being about reading a briefing paper or gaining experience simply by being near someone.  Donoghue goes back to the newspaper article.  Tsongas is rattled – she goes back to her position on Iraq but her voice is a little shaky.  Donoghue really threw her off stride.  Tsongas is slowly recovering and asks Donoghue to withdraw the ad.  Donoghue says my ad says you have no specific plan and that?s what your whole campaign is about, no specifics and no leadership.

Dick calls the whole exchange — and the evening — decidedly for Donoghue. That’s an interesting turnaround, because in previous debates I’ve felt that Donoghue has left a comfortable but somewhat bureaucratic impression. Not so last night, I guess.

Jackie Doherty was also impressed by Donoghue’s fire:

… [S]he demonstrated an articulate forcefulness and focus that was inspiring and scary to behold. (Scary because I can?t help imagining myself up there and worrying how I would handle such an onslaught.)

Anyway, check out Dick’s liveblogging of the whole debate, in six sections.

Please share widely!
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: donoghue, eldridge, finegold, ma-05, miceli, ogonowski, tsongas

20
Leave a reply

Please Login to comment
4 Comment threads
16 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
eury13mimi-pwill-weaboclippertim-little Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
cannoneo
Guest
cannoneo

A refreshing antidote to the Globe’s superficial and condescending endorsement. The argument and the tone imply there is no need for a primary at all.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
charley-on-the-mta
Guest
charley-on-the-mta

Good Lord, I’m not supporting her, but I could have rustled up something better than what the Globe drooled out. Phooey.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
jaybooth
Guest
jaybooth

Definitely a non-endorsement endorsement — did they even say anything good about her?

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
demhav
Guest
demhav

Sometimes people only see what they want to read.  I thought they were ringing endorsements!  What was interesting was the fact that neither paper bothered to even mention the other candidates. Perhaps the Globe and the Herald did not think any of the other candidates or their campaigns were noteworthy.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
tim-little
Guest
tim-little

I found the Globe’s endorsement of Tsongas about as vacant as Nikki herself is on the issues… with which, I might add, the Democratic candidates do NOT “mostly agree” — contrary to what is stated in the Globe.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
tim-little
Guest
tim-little

How does this:

<

p>

Ogonowski, a political newcomer, approaches the subject of combating terrorism not just as a person with 28 years of military experience but also as brother of the pilot of the American Airlines airplane that struck the World Trade Center on Sept. 11

<

p>
qualify someone for public office?

<

p>
Really the Globe should have staid out of this one if that’s the best they can do.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
bluetoo
Guest
bluetoo

Aww, come on.  Give me a break.  You may be supporting one of the other good Democrats in the race, but that kind of silly comment is really unnecessary and completely inaccurate.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
bluetoo
Guest
bluetoo

…are never flattering.  I was quite impressed that Tsongas secured the endorsements of both the Globe and the Herald.  In my humble opinion, that’s quite a coup. 

<

p>
And as far as raising money goes, folks can dicker all they want about what portion of Tsongas’ money was raised inside or outside the district, but the fact that she raised almost more than all the rest of these “experienced politicians” combined speaks for itself.

<

p>
I’m getting tired of seeing good Democrats trash other good Democrats. 

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
charley-on-the-mta
Guest
charley-on-the-mta

I’m simply saying I think the Globe could have done a more compelling job of it.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
bluetoo
Guest
bluetoo

…it was an enthusiastic endorsement. If I was Niki Tsongas, I’d be pretty happy with it.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
eaboclipper
Guest
eaboclipper

is that two papers with zip codes in Boston endorsed Nikki Tsongas a candidate who lives in a zip code in Boston.  The two major papers with zip codes inside the district endorsed Eileen Donoghue, a person who lives in a zip code in the district. 

<

p>
Only Jim Ogonowski got the endorsements of all 4 papers found that interesting as well.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
eury13
Guest
eury13

he’s the only real Republican candidate! No one is taking Tierney seriously. If Ogonowski hadn’t gotten all 4 endorsements, that would have been a story.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
demhav
Guest
demhav

Just like her TV ads, any change in Eileen Donoghue’s debate performances (at the end of 20 something debates), is too little, too late.  Why is there no mention on this site that the BOSTON GLOBE and the BOSTON HERALD both endorsed NIKI TSONGAS today???????  Provided Tsongas delivers the vote, this race is pretty much over.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
lynne
Guest
lynne

was scored over where Niki’s money comes from. No candidate should really honestly be getting more than 50% of their money from outside their district…hell, just raise less money and be more efficient, please. I think the figure quoted was something like 75% of Tsongas’ money is from outside. And we all know, those outsiders are not the small grassroots donor kind.

<

p>
It’ll be interesting to get the final numbers from the state when all’s said and done.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
tim-little
Guest
tim-little

That those outside donors will not be able to actually vote for Nikki on 9/4.

<

p>
I’m supporting Jamie in this race, but I must say that Eileen has continued to impress me — and last night’s showing really separated the pros (Eileen and Jamie) from the has-beens (Miceli) and the wannabes (Finegold and Tsongas).

<

p>
Tsongas in particular seems to be an empty bag — as I posted on LiL, there’s just no “there” there. At least with Miceli, there’s no mistaking where he stands!

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
will-w
Guest
will-w

Agree… Eileen was scary and appeared desperate at times. Imagine, Niki got 75% of her money from outside the district (a majority though in Massachusetts) and Eileen is SO outraged that she has to donate $450,000 to her own campaign.  If Eileen had done a better job at fundraising and communicating, she’d have had more money.  Eileen, work at success, don’t be outraged by it.

<

p>
Give Tsongas credit for a professional fundraising effort and campaign.  That also says something about the quality and capacity she’ll bring to the office. As a frontrunner that no one has hesitated to criticize, she’s handled it with grace and kept her criticism focussed on the real target – George W. Bush – the worst president ever.

<

p>
As for a plan for Veterans, today Tsongas was endorsed by the group that put on the first Veteran’s debate, so they thought she had a plan.  Along with the Globe and Herald, that’s a pretty good day for the office!

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
mimi-p
Guest
mimi-p

Will, my friend, you need to identify yourself as a Tsongas supporter and volunteer; that is one of the rules of the road in the blogsphere.

<

p>
I and other Donoghue supporters wished that we had $4,600 to donate to Eileen; we do not.  So, Eileen is not as successful as Niki in raising money.  What does that mean? 

<

p>
You are not implying that Eileen cannot represent the 5th District as well as Niki because her supporters do not have those kinds of funds or more importantly those kinds of connections?

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
cannoneo
Guest
cannoneo

“Give Tsongas credit for a professional fundraising effort and campaign.  That also says something about the quality and capacity she’ll bring to the office.”

<

p>
Yes, it does; it suggests she’ll be a competent D.C. pro, essentially CEO of a fundraising and PR operation. And her grace in ignoring criticism coincides perfectly with a strategy of maxing out name recognition with a polished image.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
demhav
Guest
demhav

What will everyone do on September 5th???????  ALL of the candidates have pledged to support the winner of the primary.  This suggests that even the candidates, all of whom have given this race their best, recognize that in order to maintain a progressive agenda (well, maybe not Micelli, who is just being a party loyalist) there is a benefit to hanging together. Otherwise we hang seperately and allow someone like George Bush to be President …. twice. No matter how dissappointed you might be that your candidate doesn’t win, you have to look at the big picture and put the sniping aside.  I could support any candidate who won, except for Miceli who is not progressive. Could everyone make that pledge………don’t answer right away……think about it.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
cannoneo
Guest
cannoneo

Is this really the REAL question???????? given that Sept. 5 is a week away? I would say the REAL!!!!!!!! question right now does not involve the assumption of one candidate winning.

<

p>
Snark aside, of course supporters of the other candidates will support the winner. This race isn’t nearly so contentious as to suggest otherwise.

You Must Be Logged In To Vote00You Must Be Logged In To Vote
2020 years ago
wpdiscuz   wpDiscuz

Election Day 2020 Countdown

Election Day 2020Countdown

Recommended Posts

  • Kerry endorses Biden (3)
  • More Media Mediocrity (3)
  • "Don't mess with me" Pelosi leads by example (2)
  • How Trump Escaped Removal From Office (May Have) (2)
  • Weymouth gas compressor: This could blow up (2)

Recent User Posts

Warren takes on Buttigieg (video)

December 7, 2019 By pogo 5 Comments

Joe Biden Doesn’t Have Enough Ethics to Sell Stamps

December 7, 2019 By bob-gardner 3 Comments

Shift away from caucuses gives advantage to Biden, Bloomberg

December 7, 2019 By Andrei Radulescu-Banu Leave a Comment

More Media Mediocrity

December 5, 2019 By terrymcginty 11 Comments

“Don’t mess with me” Pelosi leads by example

December 5, 2019 By fredrichlariccia 34 Comments

Kerry endorses Biden

December 5, 2019 By fredrichlariccia 13 Comments

Recent Comments

  • Christopher on Warren takes on Buttigieg (video)It may be, but I'd prefer that not be the premise of a B…
  • Christopher on Warren takes on Buttigieg (video)Except the gloves didn't come off that much, and if they…
  • Christopher on Joe Biden Doesn’t Have Enough Ethics to Sell StampsThe postal worker wasn't being given a gift nor was s/he…
  • fredrichlariccia on Kerry endorses Biden"Other candidates have their strong suits but on nationa…
  • fredrichlariccia on Kerry endorses Biden"Biden would restore American leadership and respect in…
  • pogo on Warren takes on Buttigieg (video)When do we place value judgements on first hand politica…
  • SomervilleTom on Warren takes on Buttigieg (video)Well, in fairness, the end of the clip (from 3:00 to the…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

Blue Mass GroupFollow

Reality-based commentary. Necessary but not sufficient. Doing the other things. Massachusetts and beyond.

Blue Mass Group
Retweet on TwitterBlue Mass Group Retweeted
PrettyGoodPhilphil@PrettyGoodPhil·
15h

This clip of @PeteButtigieg, responding to questions about why he won’t open his fundraisers to the press, is devastating. Wow.

Reply on Twitter 1203350790590664705Retweet on Twitter 12033507905906647054598Like on Twitter 120335079059066470514434Twitter 1203350790590664705
Retweet on TwitterBlue Mass Group Retweeted
TracyNovickTracy O'Connell Novick@TracyNovick·
10h

@bluemassgroup To me, it is of a piece with his seeing riding the T as a sort of fake act, rather than the act of a fellow citizen who happens currently to be serving as Governor.

Reply on Twitter 1203432201230127104Retweet on Twitter 12034322012301271042Like on Twitter 12034322012301271047Twitter 1203432201230127104
Retweet on TwitterBlue Mass Group Retweeted
TracyNovickTracy O'Connell Novick@TracyNovick·
12h

Can I just say...I genuinely do not understand Gov. Baker’s refusal to meet with people.
#mapoli
Happened here and it has happened before.
Yes, you can’t give everyone half an hour, but you can try. https://twitter.com/sunrisemvmt/status/1203385417011224577

Sunrise Movement 🌅@sunrisemvmt

"At 5 p.m., police warned protesters that if they didn't leave the building, they'd be arrested. Some sitting in front of the governor's office linked arms, and said the threat of climate change was far worse than the threat of arrest." @SunriseBoston🔥🔥
https://www.wbur.org/earthwhile/2019/12/07/sunrise-boston-arrest-green-new-deal

Reply on Twitter 1203392661484429313Retweet on Twitter 120339266148442931311Like on Twitter 120339266148442931327Twitter 1203392661484429313
Retweet on TwitterBlue Mass Group Retweeted
SayaAmeliSaya Ameli Hajebi🌅@SayaAmeli·
12h

Thanks to every young activist in @sunrisemvmt who believes in the vision of a #GreenNewDeal future, I know my words will not echo in silence.
We won't stop until every government official takes the climate crisis seriously enough to take direct action.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bostonglobe.com/2019/12/06/opinion/hope-is-not-enough/%3foutputType=amp

Reply on Twitter 1203400302310907909Retweet on Twitter 120340030231090790947Like on Twitter 1203400302310907909143Twitter 1203400302310907909
Retweet on TwitterBlue Mass Group Retweeted
ihssaneleckeyIhssane Leckey for Congress@ihssaneleckey·
6 Dec

"Get up! Get down! Keep the fossil fuels in the ground!"

This is what democracy looks like 💪🏽 #StrikeWithUs #StrikeWithUsBoston

Reply on Twitter 1202973645934678018Retweet on Twitter 120297364593467801829Like on Twitter 120297364593467801898Twitter 1202973645934678018
Load More...

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2019 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.

wpDiscuz