While we’re on the subject of conservatives occasionally being right about something, let’s talk about Jeff Jacoby’s column in today’s Globe. And let’s just ignore his idiotic first paragraph. The good part starts when Jacoby chides his fellow conservatives as follows:
let someone mention “illegal immigrants,” and your principles fly out the window. So when Governor Deval Patrick recommends allowing young illegal immigrants – residents of Massachusetts who have graduated from high school – to attend a public college and pay in-state tuition, you flip out…. You vigorously agree with Charlie Baker, a Republican candidate for governor. “If you’re illegally here, you’re illegally here,” Baker said last week. “The notion that we should treat illegal immigrants with the same benefits and opportunities that legal immigrants and legal citizens have doesn’t make any sense to me.”It is dispiriting to see Baker, a man of considerable intellectual heft, stoop to such shallow sloganeering. It is even more dispiriting to see conservatives assail immigrants instead of the insane immigration system that gave most of them no legal way to enter the United States.
And then Jacoby turns positively eloquent, making the case for in-state tuition as well as anyone I’ve ever heard:
On the whole, illegal immigrants are just the sort of newcomers Americans should embrace: self-motivated risk-takers, strivers determined to improve themselves, hard-working men and women willing to take the meanest jobs if it will give them a shot at building their own American dream. Why would we want to punish them? Why would we want to punish their kids?
A couple from Brazil, seeking a better life for themselves and their 2-month-old daughter, enter the United States unlawfully. They settle in Massachusetts, where 18 years later the girl graduates from a public high school, as assimilated and acculturated an American as her classmates in every respect – except that they are US citizens, and she, by virtue of a decision made when she was a baby, is not. Her classmates can attend the University of Massachusetts, paying $9,704 a year in tuition, the price tag for Massachusetts residents. She can attend only if she pays the out-of-state rate of $22,157; if that’s more than she can afford, she’s out of luck.
How is that a rational public policy? How is Massachusetts improved by making it impossible for an accomplished high-school graduate, a lifelong resident of the state, to gain a university degree? Who benefits when her education – along with the higher earning potential it would lead to – is cut short? She doesn’t. You don’t. Massachusetts taxpayers certainly don’t.
Jacoby then helpfully demolishes the usual line about freeloading:
Those taxpayers, remember, include illegal immigrants. More than two-thirds of illegal immigrants pay Social Security and income taxes. Between 1996 and 2003, payments from tax filers using Individual Taxpayer Identification numbers – a nine-digit substitute issued by the IRS for taxpayers ineligible for Social Security – totaled $50 billion. More than 35,000 such taxpayers, most of them illegal immigrants, annually file returns in Massachusetts.
And, finally, the bottom line, which is really startlingly well stated:
Of course illegal immigration is a problem. But it can only be solved by overhauling our dysfunctional immigration laws, not by demonizing or scapegoating illegal immigrants. Those immigrants didn’t come here in order to be lawbreakers; they broke a law in order to come here. That’s a distinction with a crucial difference – one that sensible and principled conservatives should be able to understand.
Coulda knocked me over with a feather when I finished reading that column. I’m guessing the same holds true for most of Jacoby’s fellow conservatives. Someone tell RMG.
Discuss
12 Comments . Comments are closed.Even a stuck clock is right twice a day (EOM) :-)
exactly what I thought when I read this column today n/t
Even a blind pig finds an acorn every now and then...
Gadzooks, I don't even usually read him anymore
He's generally such a hash of predictable talking points. I must have written the Globe twenty letters over the years expressing outrage at one thing or another he's said and imploring them to at least replace him with an intelligent conservative.
Thank you for promoting Jeff Jacoby
I'm such a typical liberal snob, I usually don't even bother to read him. Now I guess I'll have to.
Permission Slip
E X C U S E D
No, you don't have to read Jeff Jacoby.
In a few years, when he says something intelligent again, I'm sure it'll be picked up by David's watchful eyes.
whew!
wasn't looking forward to it to tell the truth.
Good for Jacoby
But let's be clear: that's not conservatives being right about something. That's Jacoby being right about something. That is not the conservative position.
That's why the column is so remarkable
I thought to myself, "Where did that come from?"
Too bad this compassion doesn't extend to others.
Thought maybe he plagiarized the wrong article this time. This was probably the most articulate column he's ever done. Not just mindless cut/paste of other rightwing diatribes. He's got actual numbers in this column. Real ones.
Maybe he'll recognize that some people BORN in this country, are equally hardworking, struggling, and battling mindless discrimination and an uneven playingfield. That there are lots of people trying to be good contributing members of society, and that maybe the government could give them a little help along the way. Tham maybe the blind hatred of all those "them's" that so dominates the rightwing mentality and media is wrong.
This line, for me, sums up the entire immigration debate:
No kidding.
Happy Thanksgiving Jeff. Take the big drumstick. As long as it's organic and free range, you're good. Even better if it's tofu. :-)
jacoby, alas, is human
and having a guatemalan son probably makes it harder for a human with a conscience to jump on the typical bandwagon of conservative demagoguery and bigotry.
http://www.jeffjacoby.com/5263...
For a human with a conscience, it might be harder...
...but not for Jeff Jacoby.
« Blue Mass Group Front Page
Sat 4 Feb 6:45 AM