Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

Hooray for Lawyers

July 24, 2007 By tedf

Now, I should say that I am one of the “urban drivers” whose rates could very well go up under competition unless regulations aimed at protecting urbanites prevent an increase. I should also say that I don’t see any grave problem with our current regulated system. Politically speaking, in other words, I suppose I’m opposed to a change.

That being said, what is the law on this question? The law permits the Commissioner to fix rates only if she affirmatively determines that

with respect to any territory or to any kind, subdivision or class of insurance, competition is either (i) insufficient to assure that rates will not be excessive, or (ii) so conducted as to be destructive of competition or detrimental to the solvency of insurers…

How did Burnes approach the problem? Instead of treating the problem as a political or ideological problem (“There was no ideological motivation,” she said. “I don’t have a business philosophy, really”), she treated it as a legal problem. Is competition, in fact, insufficient to assure that rates will not be excessive?

Now there are surely a lot of value judgments that go into such a decision. The clearest judgment Burnes had to make was what constitutes an “excessive” rate. But what was refreshing was that she approached the problem through the lens of the statute, which says that she is forbidden to fix rates unless there is insufficient competition. She did not start off asking how she could go about protecting our current rate-fixing system or how we could open the market to competition.

Contrast Commissioner Burnes with “lawyers” such as John Yoo or Alberto Gonzalez, yes men who have used to law to justify their boss’s policies and to insulate policymakers from prosecution rather than exercising the independent judgment regarding the law that is the lawyer’s most important job. (This may be a little unfair to Yoo, who is a scholar and who, I suppose, could in good faith hold his ridiculous views on presidential power; but it’s no surprise that he is the lawyer whom the Bush administration chose to advise it on such topics).

So while some lawyers have brought dishonor to the profession, let’s hear it for lawyers like Nonnie Burnes, who show that lawyers at our best can be the one group in our society dedicated to the law per se rather than to any particular view of politics.

(Marxists, critical theorists, etc., you may commence firing).

TedF

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: auto-insurance, burnes, lawyers

Recommended Posts

  • No posts liked yet.

Recent User Posts

Predictions Open Thread

December 22, 2022 By jconway

This is why I love Joe Biden

December 21, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Garland’s Word

December 19, 2022 By terrymcginty

Some Parting Thoughts

December 19, 2022 By jconway

Beware the latest grift

December 16, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Thank you, Blue Mass Group!

December 15, 2022 By methuenprogressive

Recent Comments

  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftSo where to, then??
  • Christopher on Some Parting ThoughtsI've enjoyed our discussions as well (but we have yet to…
  • Christopher on Beware the latest griftI can't imagine anyone of our ilk not already on Twitter…
  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftI will miss this site. Where are people going? Twitter?…
  • chrismatth on A valedictoryI joined BMG late - 13 years ago next month and three da…
  • SomervilleTom on Geopolitics of FusionEVERY un-designed, un-built, and un-tested technology is…
  • Charley on the MTA on A valedictoryThat’s a great idea, and I’ll be there on Sunday. It’s a…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

Twitter feed is not available at the moment.

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2025 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.