Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

‘ROUNDING THE GLOBE’-19: Getting personal with Larry Harmon

April 27, 2010 By bill-schechter 2 Comments

‘ROUNDING THE GLOBE’-19: Critical analysis of Boston Globe education coverage



Getting personal with Larry Harmon

Last week, the Globe finally printed two good letters on ed reform and yesterday Vaznis wrote news article on impending dismissals at Boston’s underperforming schools that actually included more teacher perspectives than I’ve seen during the entire 17-year reform era. (Of course, they were threatened with being fired). Just when I thought it might be safe to go outside again, Larry Harmon popped up on the Globe op ed page again wearing his op ed hat. (Protecting his right flank was column calling for the abolition of all municipal unions. A typically well-balanced page.  Oh, if only the Globe could run the world!)

When I am having my morning coffee and struggling my way toward consciousness, reading another Harmon education piece is always jarring. I know it means a rough ride for that day. Any chance the Globe could start publishing as an afternoon paper? I would do much better.

Anyway, I’ve decided to get personal and use this space to write Larry Harmon a letter. Nothing else has worked. Not too long ago, he told a teacher who contacted him that he was surprised to receive so little pushback from teachers. Actually, I have emailed him several times over the years and received no reply. Maybe a letter will work. I will also email him a copy. If he does respond, I will give him the space in my BMG diary that he won’t give me (or others of my ilk) on his op ed page:

******

Dear Larry Harmon,

It was said of the 19th Century novelist Horatio Alger that he wrote the same rag-to-riches novel 100 times. That’s the way I am beginning to feel about your education editorials and columns. Alger was no a literary giant, so it is easier to understand his sticking closely to a successful formula. You are an editorial writer who I experience as having been captured by a rigid perspective that no facts or nuances can penetrate. I don’t expect masterpieces from Alger, but I do expect that professional newspaper columnists will be thoughtful, even when I don’t agree with them. To take another example: I know exactly what to expect from Jeff Jacoby, but Joan Vennoci will surprise me and get me thinking. Ditto for David Brooks of the NY Times. I am just looking for some independence of mind and awareness of complexity.

Your previous column on Ravitch as well as this morning’s piece on Bill Gates (“Bill Gates’ risky adventure”) share a disturbing practice: in both instances, you summarize dissenting views without really engaging them. You seemingly use them to create an appearance of fairness, while reducing Ravitch and others to mere polemical sound bites. Strawmen are created, strawmen are knocked down.

http://www.boston.com/bostongl…

http://www.boston.com/bostongl…

I have some concerns that I would like you to engage. But first, let’s talk foundations. You clearly agree with Gates that foundations are not “dictating” education policy. I have to think you have to know that in Massachusetts there is a powerful coalition of business groups, foundations, think tanks and newspapers that are pushing a certain education agenda-an agenda you approve of. Moreover, every effort is made to marginalize other views, particularly by the Globe, which has worked hard to frame the reform issue. I feel you must know this because your newspaper is involved in that coalition. Each of these groups has every right to push for its educational vision, but let’s have some transparency and, yes, let’s examine how private money is used to shape public policy. We shouldn’t have to depend on personal emails that occasionally surface. How our public policies and institutions get “leveraged” and re-directed by organized money and media is an important and complicated issue.

OK, here are my questions/statements. Consider them a form of pushback. Your responses are sincerely invited.

• Gates speaks of charters as doing a better job. Ravitch claims that studies show that approximately 40% of charters do no better than public schools in comparable environments and that 20% do worse. What say you? Please engage.

• With respect to charter funding issues, wouldn’t you admit that those folks in Gloucester have a legitimate beef?

• Ravitch and other claim that the tests that you champion are not sufficiently valid to make high stakes decisions about students, teachers, or schools. She states that even the testing companies make no claim that they are designed to do that. Your response?

• Well, let’s assume the tests are valid and leave aside issues of whether merit pay would undermine teacher collaboration, how would you make such a system fair? After all, teachers work in such disparate environments and are assigned kids with such different ability levels even in the same school. And what about kids’ teachers before and after a particular year of testing? How are their contributions to be measured and rewarded?

• Will you acknowledge at long last that we have many terrific public schools, staffed by unions teachers, working under contracts that protect the interests of both staff and students? When you attack “teacher unions” in such a generalized way, I become unsure that you realize there is no standard union contract. MTA locals have different contracts. I mean, you do know that, right? Please make it clear that you do.

• To extend that thought, can you go so far as to say that our best public schools could serve as models for other schools, including charters, given the depth of education and range of opportunities they routinely provide in their “business-as-usual” way? If you do believe this, let’s read about it in your columns.

• Please satisfy my personal curiosity about the experiences that establish your expertise in education derives? I was a teacher for a long time. Have you taught? More important, have you visited many schools in our state? Just curious.

•  You pooh-poohed Ravitch’s contention that a business model might destroy public education. You then invited us to agree that well-intentioned Bill Gates isn’t “laying waste” to anything.  But isn’t Ravitch referring to issues of charter funding and selective enrollment, as well as the desiccating effect of test prep on the very meaning of education?

• Finally, do you agree that the institutionalized inequalities in our society-of which Mr. Gates is an eye-popping symbol-create a deeply-entrenched pattern of unequal educational opportunities? If so, why don’t you target the public policies that reinforce this pattern at least as much as you too glibly go after nefarious “teacher unions. Where is the analysis that explains why some of our kids get a great public education and other not so great? Wouldn’t such an analysis, perforce, take us into the blighted neighborhoods and struggling homes beyond the schoolhouse gate?

Thank you. If you choose to reply, consider my space yours.

Sincerely,

Bill Schechter

PS: If you are wondering about my own concessions to complexity, here they are:

-Standardized tests as one form of assessment among many;

Charters, as long as they don’t drain funds from public schools and recruit a crosssection of districts kids;

Rigorous inclassroom evaluations of teachers and administrators trained to provide

them. Incompetent teachers must be removed from classrooms, when evaluations

show them to be unfit. Please set the bar high;

-Union contracts that apply seniority consideration only where the more senior teacher is as good or better than less senior tenured faculty, as indicated by through evaluation record.

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: bill-gates, boston-globe, charters, diane-ravitch, larry-harmon, mcas, teacher-unions

Comments

  1. lisag says

    April 28, 2010 at 9:29 am

    More than 18,000 students, organized by Facebook, stood up FOR their teachers and AGAINST budget cuts, as reported by the NY Times today:

    <

    p>

    At Columbia High School in Maplewood, that looked like 200 students marching around the building waving signs reading “We are the future” and “We love our teachers.”

    In West Orange, a district that is considering laying off 84 employees, reducing busing, cutting back on music and art, and dropping sports teams, it was high school students rallying in the football stands.

    At Montclair High School, it meant nearly half of the 1,900 students gathered outside the school in the morning, with some chanting, “No more budget cuts.”

    In the largest showing, thousands of high school students in Newark marched past honking cars stuck in midday traffic to fill the steps of City Hall under the watchful gaze of dozens of police officers.

    With their protests, the students sought to send a message to Gov. Christopher J. Christie, a Republican whose reductions in state aid to education had led many districts to cut staff and programs and to ask for larger-than-usual property tax increases. Mr. Christie, who has taken on the state’s largest teachers’ union in his efforts to close an $11 billion deficit, has proposed reducing direct aid to nearly 600 districts by an amount equal to up to 5 percent of each district’s operating budget.

    <

    p>These kids must not have seen the Cartel movie (wait! that was NJ too!), read the Globe, or gotten all the memos about how corrupt and self-interested their teachers and their unions are.  

    Log in to Reply
  2. mizjones says

    April 28, 2010 at 11:34 am

    Yet another set of he-said she-said op-eds (Harmon’s) that over-simplify and push a point of view while offering superfluous “balance”.

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Posts

  • Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries (3)
  • There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing (3)

Recent User Posts

Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries

August 12, 2022 By jconway 7 Comments

There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing

August 10, 2022 By terrymcginty 8 Comments

Site issue: Unable to reply to comments

August 10, 2022 By SomervilleTom 4 Comments

Why do PUKES oppose $35 insulin for diabetics with private insurance?

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia 3 Comments

Promises made, promises kept

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia Leave a Comment

Schedule F

August 7, 2022 By johntmay 4 Comments

Recent Comments

  • SomervilleTom on Site issue: Unable to reply to commentsYes, the plugin that is broken is also the widget that p…
  • Christopher on Site issue: Unable to reply to commentsNow we seem to have lost the ability to rate comments, h…
  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesTommy Vitolo was directly responsible for the Brookline…
  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThis comment exemplifies why I'm done with "Progressive…
  • Keith Bernard on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesDon't get mad at Progressive Mass because Tommy Vitolo i…
  • fredrichlariccia on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThe other half of Wakefield (Precincts 4 - 6) is in the…
  • fredrichlariccia on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThe 9th Essex district James and I share as fellow Wakef…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

masscultural Mass Cultural Council @masscultural ·
24m

We are distributing a historic level of funding to help the state’s cultural sector recover from the impacts of the pandemic. Apply now to receive grants starting at $5K. #PowerOfCulture #mapoli https://bit.ly/Grants4Recovery

Reply on Twitter 1559899844235464705 Retweet on Twitter 1559899844235464705 Like on Twitter 1559899844235464705 Twitter 1559899844235464705
jimaloisi Jim Aloisi @jimaloisi ·
26m

A thread explaining for #mapoli the right way to think about shutting down subway service for repairs & replacement: 👇

Chris Friend @friendchristoph

I have been thinking over the last few weeks about how to think about the trade-offs between work done at nights, on weekends, and for month long shutdowns of transit lines.

So I wanted to put some numbers around those thoughts—>

Reply on Twitter 1559899329548132355 Retweet on Twitter 1559899329548132355 Like on Twitter 1559899329548132355 Twitter 1559899329548132355
massvote MassVOTE @massvote ·
34m

TONIGHT - we join our incredible partners in hosting the Second Suffolk State Senate Candidate Forum at 6:30 PM. Be sure to register now to hear what candidates have to say topics impacting Boston and Massachusetts most - https://bit.ly/3wbjiIO. #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1559897353821249536 Retweet on Twitter 1559897353821249536 1 Like on Twitter 1559897353821249536 2 Twitter 1559897353821249536
notoriousvog Notorious VOG @notoriousvog ·
38m

Boston's progressives aren’t representative of real progressive mvnt, certainly not mvnt born of #RainbowCoalition. Warren had plans for everything while running for Prez, Black/brown haven’t heard peek of plans since.

🔖#NITM☕#UrbanAgenda
#VoiceOfBlackBoston
#BOSpoli #MApoli

Sean Mannix @goldpeak1234

@scribblesonnapk @NotoriousVOG @maura_healey @AndreaForAG And this Boston resident is glad Sonia Chang Diaz is out of the race. Progressives are losing big time.

Reply on Twitter 1559896337113554950 Retweet on Twitter 1559896337113554950 Like on Twitter 1559896337113554950 1 Twitter 1559896337113554950
bryanscrafford Bryan Scrafford @bryanscrafford ·
39m

The transphobic hatred being spewed by the right now includes threats of violence against doctors and hospital staff at Boston's Children's Hospital. Sure makes it hard for the bigots to claim they're transphobic for "moral" reasons https://www.bostonglobe.com/2022/08/17/metro/right-wing-groups-hit-boston-childrens-with-barrage-threats-over-trans-health-program/ #mapoli #LGBTQ

Reply on Twitter 1559896016710782978 Retweet on Twitter 1559896016710782978 Like on Twitter 1559896016710782978 Twitter 1559896016710782978
zax2000 Mike Shaw is all vaxxed up Ⓥ @zax2000 ·
40m

Behold @CharlieBakerMA's most lasting legacy after 2 terms in office. #mapoli #MBTA

Anna Seda @viracochalvsbac

We were on our way home from a jam in Boston and had a message for Governor Baker and the Orange Line shut down: "Charlie (Baker) on the MBTA"
#boston #orangeline #mbta #publictransit #orangelinefire #30dayshutdown #charlieonthemta

Reply on Twitter 1559896002680631296 Retweet on Twitter 1559896002680631296 Like on Twitter 1559896002680631296 Twitter 1559896002680631296
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2022 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.