Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

DOMA Smacked – Federal Judge Rules it Unconstitutional

July 8, 2010 By medfieldbluebob

More to come on this, I am sure. But, in the meantime, a victory for human rights.

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: doma, glbt-rights, martha-coakley, same-sex-marriage

Comments

  1. patricklong says

    July 8, 2010 at 10:49 pm

    I like the equal protection ruling better than the 10th amendment one. In fact, the 10th amendment ruling may hurt gay rights in the long run by allowing the most backward states to continue discriminating even once Congress comes to its senses.

    <

    p>Unrelated but fun fact: Judge Tauro is the same guy who ruled that developmentally disabled individuals removed from institutions to community settings had to receive a level of care equal to or better than what they were getting in institutions. Apparently he’s good at getting himself the cases with far-reaching political impact.  

    • pablo says

      July 8, 2010 at 11:07 pm

      You think that’s why they ARE backward states?

    • simonb says

      July 9, 2010 at 1:58 am

      Tauro is also the same judge who ruled in 1998 that the Massachusetts Burma Law was unconstitutional.  (Modeled on similar laws for apartheid South Africa, the law barred the Massachusetts state government from buying goods and services from companies that did business with the Burmese military regime.)

      <

      p>In that ruling he stated that the federal government’s foreign policy powers under the constitution included micro-managing the Commonwealth’s procurement policies.

      <

      p>That’s quite a turnaround on the concept of state sovereignty.

  2. kathy says

    July 9, 2010 at 8:46 am

    I’m sure the wingnuts will cry “judicial activism!”. They were OK with activist judges who decided the Bush v. Gore case, and with Citizens United, but when it comes to the civil rights of individuals, they’ll scream to the heavens.

  3. centralmassdad says

    July 9, 2010 at 12:08 pm

    The argument is that the federal government is intruding on the regulation of domestic relations– the domain of state government– by requiring the state to violate its own laws in order to receive certain federal funding.  The state administers a veteran’s cemetery, and is funded in part by the federal government.  The state administers MassHealth, with federal funds, and in each instance must exclude people that are spouses recognized under state law.

    <

    p>Yes, I agree that the decision could be read to require the federal government to recognize state law when that law excludes SSM as well.  But this was always the case, at least until there is a 14th Amendment ground to invalidate those state laws, like in Loving.

    <

    p>This decision clarifies for me that the challenges to the individual mandate in the health care reform, made by states not individuals, probably has more to it than I previously thought.  To the extent that a state can find a hook (like the cemetary or MassHealth) it seems that there is at least a colorable argument that the individual mandate is vulnerable on 10th Amendment grounds as well.

    • mike_cote says

      July 9, 2010 at 1:59 pm

      My understanding is that the individual mandate is affected by the interstate commerce part of the US Constitution because it involves insurance companies that do interstate business and as such, the 10th Amendment does not kick in because it is by definition, federal. This is the same thing with the Arizona Law, in that immigration is federal.

      <

      p>Prior to DOMA, the federal government had never gotten involved in marriage and there are centuries of marriage laws at the state level, so the 10th amendment would definitely apply.

      <

      p>Just because the state government and the federal government disagree on something, does not make it that it must all be up to the state, or all be up to the federal government. If it were, then we would have US driver’s licences instead of MA licences and lawyers would only need to pass the US Bar instead of 50 different Bars.

      <

      p>My disappointment is that it slow down Marriage Equality in the remaining 45 states, by having to rely on the “State’s Rights” issue to defend equality.

      • centralmassdad says

        July 12, 2010 at 11:50 am

        I dont think it does much to slow down recognition in other states.  State A is not, and has never been, required to recognize a marriage from State B if State A has a public policy reason for denying that recognition.  So State A might permit marriage by first cousins, and State B, which prohibits that marriage, is under zero obligation to recognize it. DOMA Section 2 puts this into a statute, but Section 2 didn’t alter anything.

        <

        p>The only reason that this would change is if State B’s denial is unconstitutional standing alone, because it is, say unconstitutional on equal protection grounds.  The other Tauro opinion is therefore much more significant, in my view, because it has 50-state potential.

        <

        p>With respect to health insurance, I don’t think it is anywhere near so easy to conclude that it is “by definition federal.”  Insurance regulation has traditionally been a state function, which is why, if you move interstate, you probably need to change insurance carriers, and why you might presently deal with BCBS of MA, for example.

        <

        p>I’m not saying that the individual mandate is likely to be invalidated.  I’m just saying that, after reading this decision, the dismissal of these challenges is not as much of a slam dunk as I previously supposed.
         

  4. tyler-oday says

    July 10, 2010 at 9:42 am

Recommended Posts

  • No posts liked yet.

Recent User Posts

Predictions Open Thread

December 22, 2022 By jconway

This is why I love Joe Biden

December 21, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Garland’s Word

December 19, 2022 By terrymcginty

Some Parting Thoughts

December 19, 2022 By jconway

Beware the latest grift

December 16, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Thank you, Blue Mass Group!

December 15, 2022 By methuenprogressive

Recent Comments

  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftSo where to, then??
  • Christopher on Some Parting ThoughtsI've enjoyed our discussions as well (but we have yet to…
  • Christopher on Beware the latest griftI can't imagine anyone of our ilk not already on Twitter…
  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftI will miss this site. Where are people going? Twitter?…
  • chrismatth on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022I joined BMG late - 13 years ago next month and three da…
  • SomervilleTom on Geopolitics of FusionEVERY un-designed, un-built, and un-tested technology is…
  • Charley on the MTA on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022That’s a great idea, and I’ll be there on Sunday. It’s a…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

mainenewshound mainenewshound @mainenewshound ·
3h

📛MASSACHUSETTS
Raw video from inside Massachusetts Mall.
Holyoke Mall, Holyoke, #Massachusetts on Saturday, Jan 28, 2023
multiple news outlets reporting 'shooting,Innocent Bystander dead'
@NBC10Boston #mapoli #breaking
(video credit WinstonChen,MarlinaKu)
Saturday, Jan 28 2023

Reply on Twitter 1619573488557387776 Retweet on Twitter 1619573488557387776 Like on Twitter 1619573488557387776 Twitter 1619573488557387776
garyyu910 Gary Yu @garyyu910 ·
3h

Dozens of people gather #bostonchinatown for a candle light vigil, remembering all victims of CA’s latest mass shootings in Oakland, Half Moon Bay & Monterey Park
#California #MassShootings #Vigil #BayArea #SiliconValley #GunViolence
#boston #mapoli #BosPoli

4

Reply on Twitter 1619571697698627590 Retweet on Twitter 1619571697698627590 Like on Twitter 1619571697698627590 2 Twitter 1619571697698627590
b87fm Boston 87.7 FM @b87fm ·
4h

👁‍🗨Real
URBAN
Talk🎙🔥

Wake Up WOKE » FOLLOW @NotoriousVOG In The Morning M-F 7-11a, Urban Talk, News, Politics & More 📞 (617) 440-8777.

📻 87.7fm | 📲 http://B87fm.com/player
http://tun.in/sfxnB

#NITM☕
#UrbanAgenda
#BOSpoli #MApoli

Notorious VOG @NotoriousVOG

@Livinthetruth1 That sounds good. But, trust me, in a city and state where @massdems Black & white electeds practice herd endorsement simply to take the vote out of hands of #Black & #brown voters. All your comfort-food for white consumption goes out the window.

#UrbanAgenda
#BOSpoli #MApoli https://twitter.com/Livinthetruth1/status/1619545416932147201

Reply on Twitter 1619557569965481984 Retweet on Twitter 1619557569965481984 Like on Twitter 1619557569965481984 Twitter 1619557569965481984
dbernstein David S. Bernstein @dbernstein ·
5h

Very sad news in #mapoli world.

The Boston Globe @BostonGlobe

Former Cambridge mayor Alice Wolf, an advocate for refugees and LGBTQ equality, dies at 89 https://trib.al/D41o9cP

Reply on Twitter 1619551768945516544 Retweet on Twitter 1619551768945516544 Like on Twitter 1619551768945516544 3 Twitter 1619551768945516544
reveverett Rev. Laura Everett @reveverett ·
5h

Good Lord. Fatal shooting at Holyoke MA mall? #mapoli

masslivenews @masslivenews

“The victim was an innocent bystander to a confrontation between two other people,” The DA’s office said. https://www.masslive.com/police-fire/2023/01/holyoke-mall-shooting-leaves-one-innocent-bystander-dead-da-says.html?utm_campaign=masslivenews&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter

Reply on Twitter 1619549923439185920 Retweet on Twitter 1619549923439185920 1 Like on Twitter 1619549923439185920 2 Twitter 1619549923439185920
teapartyusa1 Chris Lynch @teapartyusa1 ·
5h

Memphis police permanently disband unit tied to deadly beating of Tyre Nichols https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/memphis-police-permanently-disband-unit-tied-to-deadly-beating-of-tyre-nichols/ar-AA16QpCF #DefundingThe Division #BosPoli #MaPoli

Reply on Twitter 1619548622013739008 Retweet on Twitter 1619548622013739008 Like on Twitter 1619548622013739008 Twitter 1619548622013739008
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2023 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.