Last November, the National Institutes of Health awarded the lab $802,500 in federal stimulus funds to support the recruitment of scientists specializing in regenerative biology. The lab also recently received a $10 million grant from the Massachusetts Life Sciences Center to fund renovations to the center’s Loeb Laboratory.
Now, McNamara and her co-workers say the lab doesn’t deserve the money.
“(The lab) has received a lot of taxpayer stimulus money that is expected to be used to create good jobs, not destroy them,” she said.
This story deserves attention. This trend is morally wrong, and economically harmful. Cape Cod has a dearth of living wage jobs for ordinary people. If the cape is not to become a land of retired wealthy people and downtrodden servants, this kind of outsourcing must not occur – and certainly not on the taxpayer’s dollar.
Already, according to the Cape Cod times as a result, there are houses going unbought, and further stories of economic hardship and decline:
Crystal Santiago was set to close on a new home with her fiance this month.
But three weeks ago the 27-year-old’s dreams were put on hold when officials from the Marine Biological Laboratory announced she – along with seven other housekeepers employed by the scientific institution – would be laid off and her job outsourced to an out-of-state cleaning corporation.
“I’m in a state of shock and this is very upsetting,” Santiago said. “There’s a spiraling effect, too, because I guess I won’t be taking advantage of the $8,000 (first-time homebuyer) tax credit now.”
The eight employees – all women who live on the Upper Cape – were given 30 days notice earlier this month, and are slated to work their last day on Feb. 6.
To quote one of the scientists who stayed in the lab’s housing, again from the Cape Cod times:
In an e-mail obtained by the Times and also forwarded to MBL, Ernest Couch, a biology professor at Texas Christian University, said he and his family have always been well-taken care of by McNamara and her staff.
“I completely appreciate your efforts to do what is best for the MBL,” Couch wrote. “Therefore, I appeal to you to not change the housekeeping staff to a large commercial franchise,” he said.
That sentiment was mirrored by Frederick Sweet, a professor at the Washington University School of Medicine.
“It is when the chips are down that people can discover what as individuals they are made of, and also what institutions they serve are made of,” Sweet said in an e-mail to MBL.
“Therefore, I submit that how honorably the MBL deals with its long time and loyal housekeeping workers will not only determine the lives and fates of those workers and their families, but also the soul of the MBL itself.”
How many housekeeprs are involved and what did/do they do, according to the lab’s own newsletter this spring
Q. How do you turn the rooms and cottages over quickly?
A. We rely on our dedicated staff of eight year-round employees and two summer housekeepers to do the arduous job of turning over those 2,000 beds. The
10 AM check out and 2 pm check in gives us a very narrow window. Our housekeepers must work very efficiently to meet the challenge. We are proud of how well we do. Our philosophy is ‘just do it.’Q. What is unique about MBL visitors?
A. Because students and scientists from all over the world stay here, the housing department has to be culturally sensitive and able to communicate with people for whom English is not their first language and for whom, sometimes, the American way is foreign. The staff enjoys forming friendships with people from different cultures-diversity makes our jobs more interesting.Q. Do you get to know people over the years?
A. We enjoy repeaters-individuals and families who stay in MBL housing year after year. These repeat visitors infuse familiarity and rhythm into our jobs. We enjoy watching their families grow up, returning each year a little older. It’s fun to see children of scientists come back to the MBL to work at summer jobs.Q, What are some of the rewards of the job?
A. The best part about working in the housing office comes when, after a long winter of planning and preparing, the busy season begins and we see the results of our hard work. It’s like working on a giant puzzle where each piece has to fit nicely in order for the next piece to lay flat. We’re happiest when all the various pieces fit and things run smoothly for our guests and for us. We are grateful when the system works. Sometimes people even send appreciation gifts like chocolates, flowers, t-shirts, baked goods, thank you notes, and did we mention CHOCOLATE?!Q. How do you stay sane when the season is in full swing?
A. Once the summer gets rolling, there is no rest for the housing staff. The MBL is a virtual revolving door from May through September and the staff has to juggle many things beyond room assignments and changing beds, including dispensing parking stickers and visitors’ passes, fielding phone calls from lost travelers, providing information and maps about the area, directing people to local restaurants and landmarks, managing roommate problems, and harboring lost and found items.Summers here are hectic, but fun. We try to remember to laugh a lot and to enjoy the perks of our jobs: being surrounded by the profound natural beauty of Woods Hole, being close to the Café (for coffee and company), and watching students, children, and jugglers play on the Swope lawn on summer evenings.
Where is the sense of a fiduciary responsibility to the labs, their employees, and the taxpayers who support this institution – and where is the sense of honor?
smadin says
But as someone who grew up around there: there’s no such thing as “Woods Hole Lab”: Woods Hole is just a village of Falmouth, and there are several different research institutions there; some of the major ones are Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, one of the premier ocean science labs in the world (full disclosure: my father is director of research at WHOI), the Marine Biological Lab, which looks like the one this is actually about, and the Woods Hole Research Center, of which Dr. John Holdren was the director until his appointment as science adviser to the President.
amberpaw says
I think the fired housekeepers were MBL [Marine Biological Lab] employees, per the linked newsletters, which also got the $10 million. I don’t claim to know the corporate or oganizational linkage between Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Marine Biological Lab or Woods Hole Research Center, or whether the housing referenced in the newletter may house summer staff from all of them [that is how I read it].
smadin says
It looks like it’s strictly an MBL matter, I just wanted to clarify that there are a bunch of independent entities based in Woods Hole – MBL, WHOI, WHRC, the USGS lab in Falmouth, etc., cooperate a lot but have no permanent formal organizational links that I know of. It’s not clear to me whether summer staff for the other institutions do stay in MBL’s housing, but it may be that they do. But Woods Hole itself – the village – isn’t doing this (and probably isn’t actually thrilled that MBL is!) and it doesn’t appear, at least without looking into it more carefully, that WHOI or the other institutions in the area are involved.
<
p>I apologize if I’ve sounded brusque; I’ll admit my hackled were raised a bit by the “Woods Hole is doing [X]” language because of my personal connection to WHOI, and because in my experience when people say “Woods Hole” and mean a research institution, WHOI is virtually always the one they’re talking about.
amberpaw says
I wonder what the local Woods Hole/Falmouth papers are saying. The Cape Cod paper had more than the Boston Herald, though the Herald’s story is what started me looking into the firing of these longterm, hard working, loyal housekeepers.
smadin says
The Falmouth Enterprise (called as above by locals) is Falmouth’s paper. I don’t believe there are any that are Woods Hole-specific. I can check with my folks whether they’ve noticed any coverage of the issue, but they’ve been away a lot recently going to conferences and such.
gregr says
… I would suggest that someone put these housekeepers in touch with the SEIU, ASAP.
<
p>Even small staffs can organize.
<
p>It sounds like some knucklehead who sits behind a desk all day thought he just “found” a few extra dollars in the budget. If the SEIU and Beacon Hill take notice (and maybe Capitol Hill because of the federal $$$ involved) this kind of B.S. will likely get settled amicably very quickly.
<
p>Because of the stimulus money involved, there might just be a “prevailing wage” case to be made.