Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

BU’s scary-virus biolab suffers a setback

August 6, 2006 By David 5 Comments

Waaaaay back when this blog was only about a month old, I wrote up a couple of posts based on stories about Boston University’s plans to build a “Biosafety Level 4” research facility – in which the most dangerous pathogens such as Ebola, anthrax, etc. will be studied – in Boston’s South End, one of the city’s most congested neighborhoods.  The stories arose out of BU’s total failure to follow its own protocols and state law when an outbreak of tularemia (a rare but occasionally fatal condition) occurred in an existing Level 2 research facility at BU.

I said then that locating a research facility like this in such a congested (and not coincidentally, IMHO, relatively low income) area seemed unnecessary, and a bad idea.  I also wondered whether BU was the right institution to be running this thing, in light of its miserable performance in the tularemia incident.  In a later post, a debate ensued in the comments as to whether it might in fact be necessary to have the facility where BU wanted it.

Well, it turns out that BU never thought of asking that question!  Oops.  So a judge decided last week that BU has to do a new environmental assessment to determine (1) whether alternative sites in less congested areas would be feasible, and (2) whether the risk of a “worst-case scenario” – i.e., the accidental (or, I suppose, intentional) release of a dangerous pathogen from inside the facility into the surrounding area – outweighed the benefit of locating the facility in the South End.  The judge held that, in light of BU’s failure to ask those key questions, the state’s approval of the existing assessment was “arbitrary and capricious,” and lacked a “rational basis.”  Apparently, construction work will continue while BU appeals the ruling, and the plaintiffs have not yet said that they will attempt to obtain a court order to halt construction. 

Samiyah Diaz, who is running for Dianne Wilkerson’s Senate seat (the district in which the lab would be located), issued a statement in support of the Judge’s ruling; nothing, as far as I can tell, from either Wilkerson or Wilkerson’s other opponent, Sonia Chang-Diaz.  Meanwhile, some of the project’s biggest backers – Mayor Menino and the Herald – remain undaunted in their support for building the lab. 

Undaunted, but not terribly convincing.  Here’s the Herald’s bottom line:

But to continue to deny the need for this type of facility (one of only two in the nation) near a major Boston teaching hospital instead of in a field somewhere, where research into deadly germs and viruses will allow the federal government to protect Americans from bioterrorism, is to keep one’s head buried firmly in the sand.

Of course, that makes no sense at all.  First, their facts are wrong – apparently, there are actually six operational Level 4 facilities (two in Atlanta at the CDC, and one each in Frederick, MD; Richmond, VA; Galveston, TX; and San Antonio, TX), with a couple more under construction.  Furthermore, what is the Herald’s basis for assuming a “need” to locate a facility like this one “near a major Boston teaching hospital instead of in a field somewhere”?  The Herald certainly doesn’t tell us, and indeed, the whole point of Judge Gants’s opinion is that BU hasn’t yet shown that any such “need” exists.  And, in fact, one doesn’t have to drive very far outside of Boston (or, more likely, the ‘burbs where most of these researchers probably live) to get to far less densely populated areas than the South End.  So the Herald, in classic circular logic fashion, assumes without analysis the answer to the key question, and then chastises anyone who treats the question as still an open one – even though that’s exactly what the judge found.  Great work, guys.

As for the Mayor, his own quote, which I assume was intended to show what a good idea the lab is, says it better than I ever could:

“I’d be a fool to think about putting a lab in the city that would have a catastrophic effect on the community,” Menino said in a telephone interview.

You would indeed, Mr. Mayor.

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: biolab, bu, massachusetts

Comments

  1. jconway says

    August 6, 2006 at 1:19 pm

    These people are statewide office holders, seeking another statewide office, and I personally dont see why it is against the law in the first place or why its that big of a deal, most educated people know that the state of Massachusetts as represented by a seal cant endorse a candidate, and if these people want action shots of them on the job they need to encorporate the seal into it. Real issues should trump symbolism in politics, Im tired of it being the other way around.

    Log in to Reply
    • david says

      August 6, 2006 at 1:26 pm

      you meant to post here, I think!

      Log in to Reply
  2. gallowsglass says

    August 6, 2006 at 1:55 pm

    …that the lab is going to be situated in much less populated Martha’s Vineyard?  Oh, the hue and cry there be.  All the notables would be to arms.  Legions of lawyers and politicians would work their best to stop the invasion. 

    <

    p>
    But this is the South End.  A lot of working people that don’t have time to fight BU.  Besides, it is economically easier to send staff to the South End than to an island. 

    <

    p>
    I’m sure that all the careful engineering that went into the Big Dig will go into the new building.  I’m sure security plans will be in place.  Maybe the same type of plans that puts all Masschusetts tax information and inmate records and their backups just a stone’s throw from where LNG tankers unload. 

    Log in to Reply
  3. howardjp says

    August 7, 2006 at 12:10 am

    one of the Atlanta facilities is located downtown, at Georgia State University, a short walk from Atlanta’s Underground and State House.  The lab is in the same building as some GSU classrooms.

    <

    p>
    CDC is located outside of Atlanta in an upscale area that is home to Emory University, from whom CDC acquired the land.

    Log in to Reply
  4. annem says

    August 7, 2006 at 10:14 pm

    That lab should NOT be built in the So End, and I’ve been proud that the Mass. Nurses Assoc. has taken a strong stand and lobbied hard for that postition. along with many other groups and individuals.  Thanks for the posts on this, BMG.  see last para below for pop comparison to GA lab

    <

    p>
    From Sept 2005 Z Magazine Online

    <

    p>
    “a pending bill [sponsored by] Representative Gloria Fox, whose 7th Suffolk district includes the proposed site of a high level biological laboratory, is sponsoring the bill. HR 1397, which would provide comprehensive state regulation for Biosafety Level 4 (BSL4) labs in Massachusetts. …

    <

    p>
    …The prospect of constructing a laboratory that would conduct research on some of the most deadly biological agents known to humanity—including anthrax and tularemia—in a densely populated urban area, such as Boston, has met with stiff resistance from community activists, public health advocates, peace activists, and others.

    <

    p>
    Opponents have pointed out that the neighborhood immediately surrounding the proposed site of the lab is home to about 16,721 people per square mile, over four times as many people as the 3,478 per square mile who live in the immediate vicinity of the next most densely populated BSL4 neighborhood in Atlanta, Georgia  operated by the Center For Communicable Diseases. Lab opponents also charge that situating such a lab in an area that is predominantly Latino and African American is an act of environmental racism….” 

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Posts

  • Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries (2)
  • Shout this til November (2)

Recent User Posts

Shout this til November

August 19, 2022 By fredrichlariccia Leave a Comment

Zero Net Energy – August 2022

August 18, 2022 By gmoke Leave a Comment

Liz

August 17, 2022 By johntmay 5 Comments

Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries

August 12, 2022 By jconway 12 Comments

There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing

August 10, 2022 By terrymcginty 8 Comments

Site issue: Unable to reply to comments

August 10, 2022 By SomervilleTom 4 Comments

Recent Comments

  • jconway on LizTake it from an expert, third parties are doomed to fail…
  • jconway on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesPost the interview online and let voters judge for thems…
  • johntmay on LizAs the news of Mar-a-Lago unfolds, and the economy impro…
  • johntmay on Liz“the enemy of my enemy is my friend.” Kautilya, the Hind…
  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesAs I've said several times already, the commentary on th…
  • Keith Bernard on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesI was on the interview with Rep Vitolo. He was outwardly…
  • Keith Bernard on LizFirst of all, gross. While I appreciate Ms. Cheney's cou…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

headlineoptics Headline Optics @headlineoptics ·
50m

Former Montpelier man among 3 people charged in prison slaying of James ‘Whitey’ Bulger https://www.masspolicyreport.com/2022/08/19/former-montpelier-man-among-3-people-charged-in-prison-slaying-of-james-whitey-bulger/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter @masspolicy #MApoli #Massachusetts

Reply on Twitter 1560818290511028225 Retweet on Twitter 1560818290511028225 Like on Twitter 1560818290511028225 Twitter 1560818290511028225
lowellcouncilor Darius Mitchell_ Massachusetts Governor 2022 🇺🇸 @lowellcouncilor ·
1h

America 🇺🇸 needs a GAME CHANGER!

#MAPOLI #BOSPOLI #NHPOLITICS

Alan Henney @alanhenney

CRITICAL SHOOTING, PROBABLE HOMICIDE--- 200 blk Harry S Truman Dr at Campus Way South in Largo. Man shot, reported in cardiac arrest. No suspect info yet.

Reply on Twitter 1560809927089815552 Retweet on Twitter 1560809927089815552 Like on Twitter 1560809927089815552 1 Twitter 1560809927089815552
ryanoferguson Ryan O. Ferguson @ryanoferguson ·
1h

This handshake is some cringeworthy political ad stuff #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1560808662569975809 Retweet on Twitter 1560808662569975809 Like on Twitter 1560808662569975809 1 Twitter 1560808662569975809
rwwatchma Trump's election fraud hoax undermines democracy @rwwatchma ·
2h

Defend your rights, vote 🌊 blue. #DefendDemocracy #mapoli #nhpolitics #flapol

Reply on Twitter 1560807673058267143 Retweet on Twitter 1560807673058267143 Like on Twitter 1560807673058267143 Twitter 1560807673058267143
lowellcouncilor Darius Mitchell_ Massachusetts Governor 2022 🇺🇸 @lowellcouncilor ·
2h

The TRASH, WEEDS, & POTHOLES around Lowell?

WHY DOES Lowell look 👀 so BAD as I walk THRU the city?

THE CITY LOST THE @LowellSun. AIDEN GLOBAL CAPITAL CUT THE STAFF. MOVE THE PAPER TO WESTFORD!

LOWELL NEEDS A STRONG LOWELL SUN, THAT HAS A LOCAL OWNERSHIP GROUP & CEO! #MAPOLI

Reply on Twitter 1560805370808995840 Retweet on Twitter 1560805370808995840 Like on Twitter 1560805370808995840 Twitter 1560805370808995840
ialera98 Isabelle Alera @ialera98 ·
2h

Really lucky to be working on ending the backlog of rape kits in MA with @Rep_Higgins #mapoli

WCVB-TV Boston @WCVB

Inside the State Police Crime Lab and the effort to identify rapists https://www.wcvb.com/article/inside-the-state-police-crime-lab-and-the-effort-to-identify-rapists/40944441?utm_campaign=snd-autopilot

Reply on Twitter 1560804025112662019 Retweet on Twitter 1560804025112662019 Like on Twitter 1560804025112662019 1 Twitter 1560804025112662019
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2022 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.