Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

Democrats Push Deportation-Only SAVE Act

March 5, 2008 By kyledeb

Call your representative TODAY and demand that they reject the SAVE Act!

Pressure is mounting in the Democratic-led House of Representatives to

act on the SAVE Act (HR 4088), an enforcement and deportation-only bill

introduced and sponsored by more than 140 Democratic and Republican opponents

of humane immigration reform.

[Click here] to reach your representative.

– MIRA Coalition (the link is mine)

A epic battle is being waged against anti-migrant Democrats in Congress, and it’s important that the blogosphere makes sure the pro-migrant side, the side of justice, comes out in front of this. 

But the strongest voices have been curiously silent in the face of this anti-migrant threat.

The only Daily Kos front-page mention of the SAVE Act in the last sixth months comes from a diary rescue, where Sentido makes an excellent case against the bill (migrant friend Nightprowlkitty — from docudharma — also deals out her tireless online migrant justice in the diary comments):

The Trancredo/Shuler bill, also called the “SAVE

Act” was introduced today and is the new hope of the right wing

anti-immigrant forces.

I just read it, and it is as bad as one could expect.

As expected it makes the flawed assumption that harsh law

enforcement aimed at a targeted group of people will make them simply

disappear.

This bill also lacks any indication that undocumented immigrants

should be treated as human beings… there is no family reunification,

no relief for kids who spent their whole lives here.

Cruelty has always failed as a social policy… and this bill is more evil than most.

Let’s look at how bad it can be…(read on)

Sentido – Daily Kos user

Aside from that small mention of this deportation-only bill, there hasn’t even been a recent mention of the SAVE Act in the mainstream progressive blogosphere, even by those that have been forceful in arguing against anti-migrant Democrats in the past.

This, despite the fact that there is a heated battle underway right now as some Democrats move into the anti-migrant camp, led by figures like Rahm Emanuel who has famously called immigration the “third rail of politics”.  There is a real threat of the SAVE Act being passed.  So if you don’t have time to read the rest of this post use this form to oppose the SAVE Act, and make sure Congress hears your voice.

This battle to sway anti-migrant Democrats has been very public as “hundreds of organizations representing millions of” U.S. citizens have made their opposition to the SAVE Act known.  But there has been a vicious battle behind the scenes, as well, which recently spilled over into public arena when Sam Stein of the Huffington Post got hold of a confidential document from the Coalition for Comprehensive Immigration Reform (CCIR):

Democrats may soon be taking a tougher public position on immigration,

according to a confidential study put together by key think tanks close

to the party leadership.

The study urges Democrats to adopt more rigid rhetoric when

discussing immigration by encouraging office-holders to emphasize

“requiring immigrants to become legal” rather than stressing border

enforcement and the opening of a path to legalization for the

undocumented already here.

Implicit in the report is the notion that Democrats can win wider

public support for immigration reform by framing the issue in

harsher-sound verbiage and, perhaps, policy.

This message places the focus where voters want it, on

what’s best for the United States, not what we can/should do for

illegal immigrants.

Sam Stein – Huffington Post

The fact that CCIR, an organization that has publicly opposed persecution approaches to immigration, is privately using the lure of this tougher rhetoric to keep Democrats in the “pro-migrant” camp shows just how desperate the situation has become.

Make no mistake, I completely disagree with this new messaging put forth by an organization that is supposed to be a champion of migrant-friendly comprehensive immigration reform.  Placing the focus “on what’s best for the United States, not what we can/should do for illegal immigrants” is precisely the sort of narrow nationalistic framing that I think is harmful for migrants.  Shifting towards talk of “requiring immigrants to become legal” gives into the nativistic, punitive urges of anti-migrant advocates. 

But Sam Stein makes some grave mistakes here by not reporting the broader context of this confidential study put out by CCIR.  Stein misses who is ultimately responsible for this Democrat shift towards anti-migrant rhetoric.  CCIR is not acting to push tougher rhetoric, CCIR is reacting to the anti-migrant pandering of Democrats like Rahm Emanuel, and other sponsors of the SAVE Act. 

Anti-migrant Democrats have been actively pushing their own polls with their own anti-migrant agendas.  The mainstream blogosphere has been very good about bringing this dynamic to light.  Digby has an comprehensive post about how Emanuel has been touting around pollster Stanley Greenberg to make his anti-migrant case, along with a damning indictment of the SAVE Act.  Firedoglake, through Blue America, has even taken concrete action with the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights to oust Rahm Emanuel, who represents a district that is 50% immigrant.

An article in the Hill about a recent meeting between Rahm and leaders of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus illustrates the anti-migrant position of Emanuel through his pollster, Greenberg:

Emanuel invited Democratic pollster Stanley Greenberg to the caucus meeting to discuss his polling on immigration.

Some

Democratic strategists ridiculed this idea because of Hispanic

lawmakers’ skepticism about Greenberg’s record on immigration.

In

The New Republic last month, Greenberg equated the immigration issue

with welfare reform, saying Democrats had to get tough on enforcement

before creating a path to citizenship. Many political strategists

disagree.

Jonathan E. Kaplan – The Hill

I know I’m getting into a lot of Beltway politics mumbo-jumbo here, but what I’m trying to illustrate is that it is Democrats like Rahm Emanuel that are largely responsible for the mov
e towards tougher rhetoric on migrants.  The mainstream progressive blogosphere has been very good at holding anti-migrant Democrats accountable, but now that the SAVE Act is in danger of passing, they’re nowhere to be found.  Just when their voices are needed, there is silence.

The best way to tackle this troubling move towards tougher rhetoric against migrants is by calling your Congressional representatives and telling them you oppose a deportation-only solution like the SAVE Act. 

If you haven’t gotten the message yet, please use this form to voice your opposition to the SAVE Act (I found this awesome form through a post on Street Prophets).

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: daily-kos, digby, docudharma, firedoglake, heath-shuler, huffington-post, immigration, jonathan-e.-kaplan, migrant, mira-coalition, nightprowlkitty, rahm-emanuel, sam-stein, save-act, sentido, stanley-greenberg, street-prophets, tom-tancredo

Comments

  1. tedf says

    March 5, 2008 at 6:09 pm

    Kyle, your post does not explain what the bill would do, or why, specifically, you are opposed to it and others should be.

    <

    p>What provisions do you find objectionable? The border security provisions? The employment authorization verification provisions?

    <

    p>Or do you object not to what the bill says, but what it omits? That is, do you object to a bill that focuses solely on enforcement and not on relief for illegal aliens already present in the United States, or on people abroad who would like to immigrate? Do you think it is wrong to pass an immigration bill that is not comprehensive?

    <

    p>TedF

Recommended Posts

  • No posts liked yet.

Recent User Posts

Predictions Open Thread

December 22, 2022 By jconway

This is why I love Joe Biden

December 21, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Garland’s Word

December 19, 2022 By terrymcginty

Some Parting Thoughts

December 19, 2022 By jconway

Beware the latest grift

December 16, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Thank you, Blue Mass Group!

December 15, 2022 By methuenprogressive

Recent Comments

  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftSo where to, then??
  • Christopher on Some Parting ThoughtsI've enjoyed our discussions as well (but we have yet to…
  • Christopher on Beware the latest griftI can't imagine anyone of our ilk not already on Twitter…
  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftI will miss this site. Where are people going? Twitter?…
  • chrismatth on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022I joined BMG late - 13 years ago next month and three da…
  • SomervilleTom on Geopolitics of FusionEVERY un-designed, un-built, and un-tested technology is…
  • Charley on the MTA on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022That’s a great idea, and I’ll be there on Sunday. It’s a…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

darienjj8 darien johnson @darienjj8 ·
38m

Great meeting with @macarlosgonzal1. @BECMAinc looks forward to working with you to support the small businesses of the 10th Hampden District. #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1621189060080418818 Retweet on Twitter 1621189060080418818 Like on Twitter 1621189060080418818 Twitter 1621189060080418818
grumpygrumpyowl 🦉@grumpygrumpyowl@mastodon.social @grumpygrumpyowl ·
49m

Even before these projects, MA was NOT on track to meet Global Warming Solutions Act climate goals. ANY new gas infrastructure was NOT compatible w/ GWSA goals. *Now* MA has more/better env. laws, incl. EJ laws! Unlawful permitting by State agencies don't matter, I guess? #mapoli

Adam Reilly @reillyadam

@MassGovernor @GBHNews @GreenRootsEJ @XRBoston @SlingshotAction @breathe_ns @MassClimate The big question here: should @massgovernor try to pause or halt fossil-fuel projects that advanced in the Baker years, but still aren't complete?

So far, that's not something she seems inclined to do: https://www.wgbh.org/news/politics/2023/02/02/as-healey-ramps-up-environmental-focus-some-advocates-demand-more #mapoli @gbhnews

Reply on Twitter 1621186304804327424 Retweet on Twitter 1621186304804327424 Like on Twitter 1621186304804327424 Twitter 1621186304804327424
orb3lcb GenXSomebody @orb3lcb ·
54m

This is utterly reprehensible. #mapoli
Hard No on HD.3822

Jacobin @jacobin

Prisoners in Massachusetts may soon be forced to choose between their organs and their freedom: Democratic legislators in the state are proposing a law that would allow prisoners to donate organs or bone marrow to get up to a year off their sentence. https://jacobin.com/2023/02/massachusetts-democrats-prisoner-organ-bone-marrow-donation/

Reply on Twitter 1621185031627481088 Retweet on Twitter 1621185031627481088 Like on Twitter 1621185031627481088 Twitter 1621185031627481088
teapartyusa1 Chris Lynch @teapartyusa1 ·
1h

Trump probably won't win his $50M lawsuit against Bob Woodward; the suit turns 1st Amendment on its head https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/trump-probably-won-t-win-his-50-million-lawsuit-against-bob-woodward-with-experts-saying-the-suit-turns-the-first-amendment-on-its-head/ar-AA170DmE #MaPoli #NHpolitics

Proud boys held "Free Speech" rallies at the beginning of Trump's presidency; used violence to overturn an election at the end.

Reply on Twitter 1621181115418427400 Retweet on Twitter 1621181115418427400 Like on Twitter 1621181115418427400 Twitter 1621181115418427400
jonr7007 Jonathan Rodrigues 🐜 @jonr7007 ·
1h

Organizing got @massedjustice this far. It's past time for communities like Lawrence and Boston to have true self-determination. Listen to parents, students, educators! Invest in what works, do away with failed strategies. #maedu #mapoli

https://www.bostonglobe.com/2023/02/02/metro/bill-seeks-eliminate-school-takeovers-by-mass-education-department/

Reply on Twitter 1621180690174812160 Retweet on Twitter 1621180690174812160 2 Like on Twitter 1621180690174812160 3 Twitter 1621180690174812160
repdavidlinsky David P. Linsky @repdavidlinsky ·
1h

I was honored to have met @OfficialMLK3 and @ArndreaKing on the House floor yesterday. I am deeply humbled by their commitment to advancing justice and educating & empowering our young leaders #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1621179858406760449 Retweet on Twitter 1621179858406760449 Like on Twitter 1621179858406760449 2 Twitter 1621179858406760449
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2023 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.