Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

To Protect Democracy, Diminish Judicial Review

July 2, 2021 By joeltpatterson

So, we have some real problems in America:

A lack of funding for public goods like transportation and public education.

Massive pollution in the form of methane and carbon dioxide burning up the planet (100 degrees in Seattle???).

Gerrymandering, secret political donations, and voter suppression of minorities who do not vote the way Republicans want them to.

A loss of bargaining power in the workplace and even employer interference in a worker’s private health decisions.

And in many cases, the majority of voters and legislators support solutions… yet five SCOTUS Justices can dominate the majority and reject these democratically chosen solutions through judicial review.

I want to encourage the other readers of BMG to spend fifteen minutes reading the testimony of Nikolas Bowie on the nature of judicial review as a tool to undermine democracy. I know we all had civics classes about how important judicial review is, but it is worth giving this viewpoint a good reading as it makes both a historical and a logical critique of the practice of judicial review.

(And note that gubernatorial candidate Danielle Allen’s ideas are an important part of this testimony.)

Read the whole thing.

UPDATE from August 3, 2021- Read Ian Milhiser’s explanation: SCOTUS is to blame for the wave of evictions about to harm Americans by the millions.

 

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
+1
0

Filed Under: Editor, User

Comments

  1. jconway says

    July 2, 2021 at 11:02 am

    My old friend Niko makes a compelling argument, I do wonder what happens to Brown, Griswald, and Roe in his formulae where judicial review overturned laws enacted by state and federal legislatures. Or in Hamdi v Rumsfeld where the flawed AUMF provision creating enemy combatants was passed overwhelmingly after 9/11 with just a single nay vote. On what grounds could the justices insist on restoring habeas corpus and due process rights over that democratic supermajority? I’ll have to email him these questions and invite him to respond here.

  2. Christopher says

    July 2, 2021 at 7:18 pm

    The testimony was a bit TL;DR for now, but I note that some of the most recent decisions we haven’t liked have actually upheld objectionable laws. Judicial review is more likely to become fraught when laws are overturned. That said, in a constitutional republic all the branches have legitimate roles to play even if some mandates have more democratic origins than others. We’re often taught the Marbury case established judicial review, but really how else can you interpret the combination of the supremacy and appellate jurisdiction clauses. I do think expanding the Supreme Court to one Justice per circuit makes sense, but frankly our side just has to get better at caring about judicial picks when campaigning for Senate and the Presidency.

    • joeltpatterson says

      July 4, 2021 at 11:13 am

      “I do think expanding the Supreme Court to one Justice per circuit makes sense, but frankly our side just has to get better at caring about judicial picks when campaigning for Senate and the Presidency.” I wholeheartedly agree. I think the way we motivate our voters, activists, and elected officials is by pointing out key facts: For only about 10 years was there a progressive majority on SCOTUS, and the current Federalist Society judges are deliberately misreading the intent of the Reconstruction Amendments and the Voting Rights Act. We can not allow this.
      –and I encourage you to take a second read at it. Though long, its ideas are important, and I have already had one longtime Democrat attorney tell me this testimony is a gamechanger for him.

  3. joeltpatterson says

    July 4, 2021 at 11:22 am

    Is the Supreme Court Nullifying The Voting Rights Act Bad?
    Poli sci PhD Scott Lemieux pushes back on an opinion by Econ PhD Kevin Drum:

    the Voting Rights Act, as amended in 1982, forbids state election laws that have a disparate effect on racial minorities, irrespective of facially neutral language. Drum apparently agrees with John Roberts that Congress should have narrowed the VRA rather than expanded its reach, but Congress concluded that racially discriminatory election laws were bad, and the Supreme Court’s job is to enforce the policy choice made by the legislative enactment, not the alternative proposed by hacks in Reagan’s Department of Justice. Alito’s opinion, however, simply acted as if Roberts had won rather than lost the argument, a grossly inappropriate abuse of judicial power.

    This is exactly the kind of thing Bowie is talking about–six people are dominating the will of Congress and the majority of the people… and ignoring the intent of the Reconstruction Amendments and the VRA. Judicial review must be curtailed if not ended because judicial review is a tool in the hands of those who want to suppress the votes of minorities, thereby reducing democracy in America.

    • Christopher says

      July 4, 2021 at 6:20 pm

      As I recall the objection to VRA was that the pre-clearance provisions only applied to some jurisdictions based on the history of those jurisdictions. It would be easy for Congress to simply require that all jurisdictions play by the same rules despite some having proven more reliable than others.

  4. joeltpatterson says

    July 11, 2021 at 11:02 am

    Also, The Supreme Court has been controlled by conservatives since 1970. More good information on how these few people dominate the majority of the nation. Remember that Democratic Presidential candidates have won 7 of the past 8 popular votes. https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/supreme-court-uber-conservative-few-recent-decisions-don-t-change-ncna1273014

Recommended Posts

  • No posts liked yet.

Recent User Posts

Predictions Open Thread

December 22, 2022 By jconway

This is why I love Joe Biden

December 21, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Garland’s Word

December 19, 2022 By terrymcginty

Some Parting Thoughts

December 19, 2022 By jconway

Beware the latest grift

December 16, 2022 By fredrichlariccia

Thank you, Blue Mass Group!

December 15, 2022 By methuenprogressive

Recent Comments

  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftSo where to, then??
  • Christopher on Some Parting ThoughtsI've enjoyed our discussions as well (but we have yet to…
  • Christopher on Beware the latest griftI can't imagine anyone of our ilk not already on Twitter…
  • blueeyes on Beware the latest griftI will miss this site. Where are people going? Twitter?…
  • chrismatth on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022I joined BMG late - 13 years ago next month and three da…
  • SomervilleTom on Geopolitics of FusionEVERY un-designed, un-built, and un-tested technology is…
  • Charley on the MTA on This site (will be disabled on) December 31, 2022That’s a great idea, and I’ll be there on Sunday. It’s a…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

activate_media Activate Media @activate_media ·
57m

8PM ET NonVisual Radio
Tunes from Beaver Brown Band
Activate Radio http://activatemedia.org
#boston #cambridge #dorchester #mattapan #roxbury #jp #lowell #worcester #fallriver #springfield #bospoli #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1621671883786551297 Retweet on Twitter 1621671883786551297 Like on Twitter 1621671883786551297 Twitter 1621671883786551297
mainenewshound mainenewshound @mainenewshound ·
57m

📛📛📛 REPORTS OF A 3RD CHINESE SPY BALLOON .....ADSB EXTREMELY BUSY ONE COBRA UP
#mepolitics #breaking #mapoli #nhpolitics

Reply on Twitter 1621671763443580928 Retweet on Twitter 1621671763443580928 Like on Twitter 1621671763443580928 Twitter 1621671763443580928
mainenewshound mainenewshound @mainenewshound ·
58m

📛📛📛 REPORTS OF A 3RD CHINESE SPY BALLOON .....ADSB EXTREMELY ONE COBRA UP
#mepolitics #breaking #mapoli #nhpolitics

Reply on Twitter 1621671655226343430 Retweet on Twitter 1621671655226343430 Like on Twitter 1621671655226343430 Twitter 1621671655226343430
notoriousvog Notorious VOG @notoriousvog ·
1h

Big homie @kendricklamar has a Book Tour: "THE EDUCATION OF KENDRICK PERKINS." He's doing a VIRTUAL Premiere Signing online 2/20 & LIVE in Somerville, MA—TUESDAY, Feb 21, 7pm @ArtsattheArmory!

Support the EVERYBODY's @celtics! #BOSpoli #MApoli

More info https://read.macmillan.com/lp/education-of-kendrick-perkins-tour/

Reply on Twitter 1621668695759065089 Retweet on Twitter 1621668695759065089 Like on Twitter 1621668695759065089 Twitter 1621668695759065089
mysteriousrook Ed Lyons @mysteriousrook ·
1h

This was a very good, comprehensive account by just-departed Sec. of Ed James Peyser of what the Baker admin did for #mapoli education and what Gov. Healey could do — in @CommonWealthMag. https://commonwealthmagazine.org/education/baker-education-legacy-continuity-and-change/

Reply on Twitter 1621667626492596224 Retweet on Twitter 1621667626492596224 Like on Twitter 1621667626492596224 1 Twitter 1621667626492596224
activate_media Activate Media @activate_media ·
1h

TODAY AT 8 PM
The Shaskeen Presents: TREE, Inverter and specials guests
The Shaskeen Pub and Restaurant · Manchester https://buff.ly/3jrvtOw
#boston #cambridge #dorchester #mattapan #roxbury #jp #lowell #worcester #fallriver #springfield #bospoli #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1621666134264102913 Retweet on Twitter 1621666134264102913 Like on Twitter 1621666134264102913 1 Twitter 1621666134264102913
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2023 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.