Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

What the GITMO Files Reveal About State Secrecy

April 27, 2011 By ACLUm blog Leave a Comment

by Kade Crockford

As researcher Darryl Li points out, most of the Wikileaks Gitmo dump consists of US intelligence “’detainee assessments’ that reveal more about the inner fantasy world of the US intelligence apparatus than who the detainees really are.”

Li reminds us of Hannah Arendt’s insightful reading of the Pentagon Papers. Poring through these DoD papers, Li writes, she was “struck by the bureaucratic self-deception and “defactualization” that thrive in environments of official secrecy, and the same rings true here: The Guantanamo jailers saw what they wanted to see – and found what pressures from above and their own cultural presuppositions pushed them to find.” (Emphasis mine.)

We have known for a long time that Gitmo was built on a foundation other than the rule of law. These documents show us that the world inside of Gitmo has been constructed purely by the US military imagination, where officials are free to conjure up demons out of thin air (i.e. the Casio watch) in an environment shrouded from public scrutiny. The democratic processes of press oversight and extra-military accountability (for example, in US courts) that would have encouraged a basic separation of fact from fiction regarding its prisoners and their supposed ‘crimes’ have been systematically excluded from the space. Our state apparatus and its willing apparatchiks in Congress warn us that we mustn’t know, lest the terrorists win.

The Wikileaks Gitmo files reveal the extent to which the fundamental separation of innuendo, rumor or pure fabrication from studied, provable fact helped to construct and maintain an environment in which torture and humiliation became common practice. Nothing was certain; therefore everything was permissible. But crucially, the recently leaked intelligence assessments never mention US torture of prisoners. Therefore the ‘defactualization’ process is not simply marked by carelessness, innocent omission, and cultural bias; it is fundamentally a fictional process, with less than savory and legally troublesome details purposefully excluded from the official record.

This nightmarish scenario adds a twist to the Red Queen’s declaration: “Sentence first…verdict afterwards!” In Gitmo, it has always been, “Sentence first…verdict unnecessary!” Or perhaps better stated, “Sentence first…verdict secret!”

Just as Hannah Arendt discovered when she read through the Pentagon Papers, we can now confirm that the most dangerous part of Gitmo’s operation was and is that the detention regime operates behind an iron wall of secrecy. There can be no open trials, no public hearings of evidence or defense. Justice Damon Keith’s famous warning that “democracies die behind closed doors” seems like a quaint reminder of a more innocent time, when ‘serious’ people could openly debate the value of secrecy or transparency.

But his warning is more relevant than ever, for our society at large. As our government quietly develops and extends its vast surveillance network throughout the nation and the world, we should remember that it is secrecy itself that is the enemy of freedom.

The government will always claim that secrecy protects us, but Gitmo painfully demonstrates that this is a false claim. It should come as no surprise now, after ten years of blatant extra-legality and government sponsored terror, to find that state secrecy often exists solely to protect the government from embarrassment or charges of criminality. Tragically, our courts have not stepped in to fulfill their constitutional mandate to check those abuses.

For the prisoners on the island base, the overwhelming majority of whom have not been – and likely never will be — convicted of any crime, Gitmo is the horrific marriage of Orwellian and Kafkaesque nightmares. It is a regime constituted by torture and humiliation mixed with bureaucratic denials and ‘mistakes’ that can’t be corrected, governed under a top-to-bottom prohibition against meaningful accountability or challenge, wrapped up neatly in a package of immunity and secrecy.

As Thomas Paine said, “He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty, he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself.”

If we allow our government to continue to operate behind the thick wall of state secrecy, we won’t know when our enemy is being oppressed. And when we allow for the destruction of others’ liberty in secret, we endanger ourselves further, for we won’t even know when our own liberty has been usurped.

The Gitmo files reveal what secrecy begets. Let us take heed of that warning as it applies to all of us, imprisoned in a CIA black site, locked up indefinitely without charge in Guantanamo, or not.

Kade Crockford is Privacy Rights Coordinator at the ACLU of Massachusetts. You can contact her at kcrockford [at] aclum [.] org.

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: bush, courts, gitmo, gtmo, guantanamo, guantanamo-bay, justice, leaks, liberty, marines, military, military commissions, obama, rule-of-law, secrecy, us, war-on-terror, wikileaks

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Posts

  • There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing (3)
  • Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries (2)
  • Promises made, promises kept (2)
  • IRA passes 51- 50! (1)
  • Real “Center” is Economically Nationalist/Culturally Moderate (1)

Recent User Posts

Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries

August 12, 2022 By jconway 1 Comment

There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing

August 10, 2022 By terrymcginty 8 Comments

Site issue: Unable to reply to comments

August 10, 2022 By SomervilleTom 2 Comments

Why do PUKES oppose $35 insulin for diabetics with private insurance?

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia 3 Comments

Promises made, promises kept

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia Leave a Comment

Schedule F

August 7, 2022 By johntmay 4 Comments

Recent Comments

  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesI appreciate you writing this diary. This primary seems…
  • fredrichlariccia on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingKLEPTOCRAT GRIFTERINO is not the VICTIM; he's the PERPET…
  • Christopher on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingRepublicans: How dare Merrick Garland politicize the DOJ…
  • fredrichlariccia on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingThe Court has just given Trump until 3 pm tomorrow to ap…
  • fredrichlariccia on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingAG Garland just announced the search warrant has been un…
  • johntmay on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingI would not be surprised at all to learn that Trump deli…
  • fredrichlariccia on There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This TimingCould it also mean that KARM-A-LAGO might want to divert…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

headlineoptics Headline Optics @headlineoptics ·
1h

The Column: Signs of the times? – Lowell Sun https://www.masspolicyreport.com/2022/08/14/the-column-signs-of-the-times-lowell-sun/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter @masspolicy #MApoli #Massachusetts

Reply on Twitter 1558673528496332803 Retweet on Twitter 1558673528496332803 Like on Twitter 1558673528496332803 Twitter 1558673528496332803
rwwatchma Trump's election fraud hoax undermines democracy @rwwatchma ·
1h

Arizona Speaker of the House Republican Rusty Bowers on Trumpism:

"The rule by thuggery and intimidation. They found a niche, they found a way, and it's fear. People can use fear, demagogues like to use fear as a weapon. And they weaponize everything."

#mapoli #nhpolitics

Aaron Rupar @atrupar

Rusty Bowers on Trumpism: "The rule by thuggery and intimidation. They found a niche, they found a way, and it's fear. People can use fear, demagogues like to use fear as a weapon. And they weaponize everything."

Reply on Twitter 1558672251893022720 Retweet on Twitter 1558672251893022720 Like on Twitter 1558672251893022720 1 Twitter 1558672251893022720
stevenl57 Steve Leibowitz @stevenl57 ·
1h

So there was a tweet from Senator Warren that the #MBTA mess is on the Governor. She's not wrong, but it is incomplete. You can debate the pie slice, but you cannot exclude the Legislature on this, where the culture of kicking cans down the road, prevails. #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1558670098029846530 Retweet on Twitter 1558670098029846530 Like on Twitter 1558670098029846530 Twitter 1558670098029846530
lowellcouncilor Darius Mitchell_ Massachusetts Governor 2022 🇺🇸 @lowellcouncilor ·
2h

JOE BIDEN, KAMALA HARRIS, THE CONGRESSIONAL BLACK CAUCUS HAS SHOWN ZERO PASSION OR EMOTIONAL CONNECTION FOR BLACK AMERICA 🇺🇸! IT’S OLD! THEY ARE OLD!!

THE PARTY OF SLAVERY! THAT’S WHAT WE ARE WITNESSING!

#MAPOLI #BOSPOLI #NHPOLITICS

Reply on Twitter 1558662516443680769 Retweet on Twitter 1558662516443680769 1 Like on Twitter 1558662516443680769 2 Twitter 1558662516443680769
headlineoptics Headline Optics @headlineoptics ·
2h

The Perils of Not Paying Property Taxes In Massachusetts Illustrated In Bourne Case https://www.masspolicyreport.com/2022/08/13/the-perils-of-not-paying-property-taxes-in-massachusetts-illustrated-in-bourne-case/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter @masspolicy #MApoli #Massachusetts

Reply on Twitter 1558660820153749507 Retweet on Twitter 1558660820153749507 Like on Twitter 1558660820153749507 Twitter 1558660820153749507
rwwatchma Trump's election fraud hoax undermines democracy @rwwatchma ·
2h

MAJOR LEGISLATION BIDEN YEAR 1,2
Bipartisan x4
👉🏼Infrastructure Deal
👉🏼Gun Deal
👉🏼Chinese Competition Deal
👉🏼Toxic Burn Pit Healthcare Benefits Deal for Veterans
Voters❤️Bipartisan

👉🏼Partisan Prescription Drugs Deal
👉🏼Obamacare Subsidies
👉🏼Covid Recovery Act
#mapoli #nhpolitics

Morning Joe @Morning_Joe

Reply on Twitter 1558660805083668480 Retweet on Twitter 1558660805083668480 Like on Twitter 1558660805083668480 Twitter 1558660805083668480
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2022 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.