Blue Mass Group

Reality-based commentary on politics.

  • Shop
  • Subscribe to BMG
  • Contact
  • Log In
  • Front Page
  • All Posts
  • About
  • Rules
  • Events
  • Register on BMG

How to Win In Boston: Race, Class, or Being Michelle Wu

November 9, 2013 By Benjamin Day 3 Comments

Boston’s 2013 municipal election was extraordinary not just as the first open Mayoral race in twenty years or the free-wheeling preliminaries, but because Marty Walsh and Michelle Wu secured victory with very unorthodox neighborhood coalitions.

Municipal campaign managers often speak of New Boston vs. Old Boston during elections. New Boston consists of communities of color and the group of progressive white neighborhoods (Jamaica Plain, South End, Back Bay, Beacon Hill) that usually vote with them. Old Boston refers to the ethnic white working class neighborhoods and more conservative middle-class white neighborhoods that also vote together, such as the South Boston, Charlestown, North End, Hyde Park, West Roxbury, etc. Over the decades a growing share of Boston’s population consists of people of color, however, leading to new possibilities for candidates of color and new political dynamics for all city-wide candidates.

Three of the four winning At-Large City Council candidates cruised to victory the traditional way. Compare these google maps I put together for voter percentages for Ayanna Pressley and Michael Flaherty:

% Votes for Ayanna Pressley, by Precinct

% Votes for Ayanna Pressley, by Precinct (click for interactive google map)

% Votes for Michael Flaherty, by Precinct

% Votes for Michael Flaherty, by Precinct (click for interactive google map)

The map of Stephen Murphy’s precinct votes looks similar to Flaherty’s, and they are both mirror images of Pressley’s base. Pressley was elected by New Boston, Flaherty and Murphy by Old Boston.

The first surprise of the 2013 elections was that the Mayoral race was decided more along class lines than the traditional New vs. Old Boston alliances. South Boston went strongly for Walsh, breaking ranks from middle-class white neighborhoods like West Roxbury. High-income progressive white neighborhoods like Beacon Hill, Back Bay, and the South End backed Connolly, breaking ranks with communities of color. My neighborhood of Jamaica Plain, which looks like an extension of Roxbury on most electoral maps, was split exactly down the middle – 50% for Walsh, 50% for Connolly – and zooming in on my map of the Mayoral votes by precinct will show you that Connolly captured the higher-income whiter precincts in central western JP, while eastern JP, the Latin Quarter, and the Forest Hills neighborhoods went for Walsh:

% Gap in Mayoral Votes, By Precinct

% Gap in Mayoral Votes, By Precinct (click for interactive google map)

The final surprise was Michelle Wu’s rookie 2nd place finish, which she accomplished with an unusual geographic base. Wu cleaned up in progressive white neighborhoods like Jamaica Plain, South End, Back Bay, and Beacon Hill. In addition, her base extended to Fenway/Kenmore and Allston. However, aside from Chinatown and a few areas of Roxbury, she did not perform as well in communities of color. This is an unusual coalition of neighborhoods to line up behind the same candidate, and to pull it off Wu needed extraordinarily high turnout from all of them, which she got: more than 91 precincts gave Wu 20% or more of their votes (the precincts in the darkest green). To put that in perspective, Michael Flaherty and Stephen Murphy together had only 44 precincts deliver 20% or more votes:

% Votes for Michelle Wu, by Precinct

% Votes for Michelle Wu, by Precinct (click for interactive google map)

As usual, the at-large candidates who did not make the cut had trouble breaking out of the neighborhoods they live or work in. Follow these links to pull up voting maps for any of the remaining candidates:

  • Annissa Essaibi-George
  • Jeffrey Michael Ross
  • Martin Keogh
  • Jack Kelly

 

Please share widely!
fb-share-icon
Tweet
0
0

Filed Under: User Tagged With: 2013 Elections, Annissa Essaibi-George, ayanna-pressley, boston, elections, jack kelly, jeff-ross, john-connolly, Martin Keogh, marty-walsh, mayor, michael-flaherty, Michelle Wu, Stephen Murphy

Comments

  1. thinkliberally says

    November 10, 2013 at 12:47 pm

    But first…

    I wonder if principles, personal achievements, or the issues have anything to do with voting? – promoted by Bob_Neer

    Ok, Bob. I’ll bite. What does Michelle Wu believe? Anyone?

    Ben, good job showing how unusual this Mayoral election really was. This was an election that broke more along economic lines than traditional demographic lines. As you point out, Jamaica Plain was/is a microcosm of this new split. Really going to be an interesting four years to see how Marty holds it together.

    Log in to Reply
    • jconway says

      November 10, 2013 at 2:42 pm

      While I would be the first to take issue with the idea we are living in a post-racial society, I do think race is mattering less to urban politics. De Blasio’s biracial family was an asset where it would’ve been a liability (in both white and black communities) just 10-15 years ago. Class, particularly in urban elections, is becoming a greater barometer of voting preferences. I hope in as cultural issues recede in the background, state and national elections will be determined in issues of economic fairness.

      Log in to Reply
      • thinkliberally says

        November 10, 2013 at 5:42 pm

        …I’m glad you acknowledged we have a ways to go. The DeBlasio ad was remarkable, but we’re not there yet. The poverty numbers as correlated to race remain surprising, even in Boston. Educational achievement, even advancement in our police and fire forces are linked to race. And all you have to do is read the comments sections of the Herald and even the Globe to see how far we have to go.

        What I agree, though, is that there is the beginnings of an understanding that the low- and moderate-income white families of South may have more in common with low- and moderate-income families of Roxbury than they do with upper middle income white families of West Roxbury.

        Just the beginnings, though. Let’s recognize that had it been Connolly v. Barros or Richie or Arroyo, the coalitions would have aligned very differently.

        Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Posts

  • Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries (3)
  • There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing (3)
  • Promises made, promises kept (1)
  • Real “Center” is Economically Nationalist/Culturally Moderate (1)

Recent User Posts

Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid Primaries

August 12, 2022 By jconway 7 Comments

There Is Not A Chance the White House is Happy With This Timing

August 10, 2022 By terrymcginty 8 Comments

Site issue: Unable to reply to comments

August 10, 2022 By SomervilleTom 2 Comments

Why do PUKES oppose $35 insulin for diabetics with private insurance?

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia 3 Comments

Promises made, promises kept

August 8, 2022 By fredrichlariccia Leave a Comment

Schedule F

August 7, 2022 By johntmay 4 Comments

Recent Comments

  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesTommy Vitolo was directly responsible for the Brookline…
  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThis comment exemplifies why I'm done with "Progressive…
  • Keith Bernard on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesDon't get mad at Progressive Mass because Tommy Vitolo i…
  • fredrichlariccia on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThe other half of Wakefield (Precincts 4 - 6) is in the…
  • fredrichlariccia on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesThe 9th Essex district James and I share as fellow Wakef…
  • fredrichlariccia on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesYou hit the nail on the head here. Namely: Holier than T…
  • SomervilleTom on Progressive Mass Shouldn’t Back Stupid PrimariesI appreciate you writing this diary. This primary seems…

Archive

@bluemassgroup on Twitter

#mapoli

dvchavez Doug Chavez @dvchavez ·
1h

Plymouth county get your @Hall4DA sign! While you are at it sign up to volunteer or donate! Every hour you can give counts! Every dollar you can give counts! #Hall4DA #mapoli

Rahsaan Hall @rahsaandhall

You wanted them, so we made them! Team #Hall4DA yard signs are here!

Request yours now at https://hall4da.com/yardsigns and let your neighbors know that you're ready to reclaim the spirit of justice in Plymouth County. #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1559280416724598784 Retweet on Twitter 1559280416724598784 Like on Twitter 1559280416724598784 Twitter 1559280416724598784
tanisha4ma Tanisha Sullivan, Candidate for MA Sec. of State @tanisha4ma ·
1h

If ⁦@BillGalvin4MA⁩ hadn’t BLOCKED a lawsuit in 2017 challenging the state’s requirement that eligible voters register 20 days before an election, we would have same-day voter registration today. His reason? “Paperwork.” This moment demands so much more #mapoli #democracy

Reply on Twitter 1559280101887459328 Retweet on Twitter 1559280101887459328 1 Like on Twitter 1559280101887459328 2 Twitter 1559280101887459328
framsource FraminghamSource @framsource ·
1h

OPINION: Vote To Increase MCAS Score Required To Graduate is 'Disappointing' https://framinghamsource.com/index.php/2022/08/15/opinion-vote-to-increase-mcas-score-required-to-graduate-is-disappointing/
@SousafortheCity @SousaforRep @framinghamps #Frampoli #Mapoli #Framingham

Reply on Twitter 1559277697808973824 Retweet on Twitter 1559277697808973824 Like on Twitter 1559277697808973824 Twitter 1559277697808973824
petertpiazza Peter Piazza @petertpiazza ·
1h

This move is:

A) Harmful (more kids will be labeled "failing" during an ongoing pandemic)
B) Backwards (only 11 states use graduation exams, down from 27)
C) Un-democratic (225 of 229 public comment were against this)
D) All of the above!

https://www.bostonglobe.com/2022/08/15/metro/state-education-board-vote-today-raising-mcas-graduation-requirements/ #MAedu #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1559276948563582979 Retweet on Twitter 1559276948563582979 1 Like on Twitter 1559276948563582979 6 Twitter 1559276948563582979
dscush Dan Cusher @dscush ·
1h

This comparison is beyond repugnant. I wish I could say #mapoli is better than this, but here we are...

Patrick Kearney @RepKearney

On January 6, people DIED, because Trump told lies about election integrity. @cdempc says he voted in every election since 06 but is shown skipping ‘16 and ‘20 primaries . Can we get some clarification @BillGalvin4MA @Tanisha4MA @DianaDiZoglio? #mapoli

Reply on Twitter 1559276563073482752 Retweet on Twitter 1559276563073482752 Like on Twitter 1559276563073482752 Twitter 1559276563073482752
swearobics Wokational_school @swearobics ·
1h

Lies, damn lies, and Boston Globe reporters.
@bostonherald @GlobeOpinion
#bospoli #mapoli #boston #redsox #celtics #bruins #patriots

Wokational_school @swearobics

Thread 1/3
Is @marcela_elisa working for the Arroyo campaign? She made a big deal about Mijente endorsing Arroyo. In her Globe article she implied that Mijente was a large organization. Boy was she trying to pull the wool over everyones eyes!!
#Bospoli #Mapoli #boston #RedSox

Reply on Twitter 1559276491845750784 Retweet on Twitter 1559276491845750784 Like on Twitter 1559276491845750784 2 Twitter 1559276491845750784
Load More

From our sponsors




Google Calendar







Search

Archives

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter




Copyright © 2022 Owned and operated by BMG Media Empire LLC. Read the terms of use. Some rights reserved.